Hajime Hoji .Language Faculty Science
Cambridge University Press

cover image
© Cambridge University Press

EPSA [31]-4 (=[31]-11)

This is discussed in Chapter 6. It is one of the two Main-Experiments in English discussed in the CUP book. The other Main-Experiment in English is [31]-5 (=[31]-12), which is discussed in Chapter 7, along with Japanese Experiments. There are three SGs, but SG3 is not discussed in the CUP book and the result charts below exclude SG3. But, the results on SG3 are included in the "Raw Data" files given below. LG1: BVA(every boy, his); LG2: BVA(no boy, his)

Design

[31]-4 Design

Examples

[31]-4 Examples

Results

Effects of informant classification on a *Schema-based prediction

[31]-4 Summary

[31]-4 Schema-group-based

[31]-4 Lexical-group-based

[31]-1 Summary

[31]-1 Lexical-group-based

Informant list for [31]-4:
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

This means that the informant classification is based on the result of [31]-1, only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)).

[31]-4 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Summary

[31]-11 Lexical-group-based

[31]-8 Summary

[31]-8 Lexical-group-based

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no

This means that the informant classification here is based on the result of [31]-8, only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)).

[31]-11 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)).

[31]-11 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-4:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)).

[31]-4 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-7

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-7.

[31]-11 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-4:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-7

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-7.

[31]-4 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-7; &
based on: [31]-13

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-7 and [31]-13.

[31]-11 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-11 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-4:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-7; &
based on: [31]-13

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-7 and [31]-13.

[31]-4 Summary, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-4 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list

See the Results of [31]-3 (=[31]-10) for the absence of similar effects of informant classification in the case of Binding Condition C/D.

Effects of informant classification on okSchema-based predictions

[31]-11 Schema-group-based

[31]-8 Summary

[31]-8 Lexical-group-based

[31]-1 Summary

[31]-1 Lexical-group-based

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)). (This has been given above.)

[31]-11 Schema-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-9 Summary

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-9

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-9.

[31]-11 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list

[31]-2 Summary

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-9, &
based on: [31]-2

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-9 and [31]-2.

[31]-11 Schema-group-based, based on the above informant list


Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)). (This has been given above twice.)

[31]-11, Schema-group 2, Summary, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-9, &
based on: [31]-2

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-9 and [31]-2.

[31]-11, Schema-group 2, Summary, based on the above informant list


[31]-11 Lexical-group-based

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)). (This has been given above three times.)

[31]-11, Schema-group 2, Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-9, &
based on: [31]-2

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)), and also based on [31]-9 and [31]-2.

[31]-11, Schema-group 2, Lexical-group-based, based on the above informant list

The one-sentence-at-a-time test type vs. the three-sentences-at-a-time test type

We are considering only Schema groups 1 and 2.

[31]-4 One sentence at a time

[31]-4 Three sentences at a time

[31]-11 One sentence at a time

[31]-11 Three sentences at a time

Informant list for [31]-11:
based on: [31]-8, every; &
based on: [31]-8, no; &
based on: [31]-1, every; &
based on: [31]-1, no; &
based on: [31]-9, &
based on: [31]-2

The informant classification is based on [31]-1 as well as [31]-8 only considering Lexical groups 1 and 2 (BVA(every boy, his) and BVA(no boy, his)).

[31]-11, One sentence at a time, based on the above informant list

[31]-11, Three sentences at a time, based on the above informant list

Raw data

[31]-4 Raw Data

[31]-11 Raw Data