Follow-Ups :
 No Follow-Ups
MENU
O Hajime Hoji's HP Top
.
o Research Interests
o What's New
O Discussion
.
o General Remarks
o Remarks
o Past Postings
O Works
.
o Downloadable Papers
o List of Publications
o Conference/Workshop Presentations
o Invited Talks
o Abstracts
O Works by other linguists (downloadable papers included)
.
o Works by Ayumi Ueyama (including her 1998 thesis)
o Works by J.-R. Hayashishita
o Works by Teruhiko Fukaya
o Works by Satoshi Kinsui
o Other Works
LINKS
O Dept of Ling, USC

O Ayumi Ueyama's webpage (written mostly in Japanese)
O Satoshi Kinsui's webpage (written mostly in Japanese)
O Jason Merchant's webpage
E-MAIL
You can e-mail me at: hoji [at] usc.edu
Mailing address
Department of Linguistics
University of Southern California
Los Angeles, California 90089-1693
U.S.A.
......
General Remarks
@
Subjects (Tree) Subjects (Date) Postings (List)

[44338] Hajime Hoji (→ [44337]) Apr/18/2014 (Fri) 13:51
That is an empirical question
In that part of the video, we see an exchange like the following between Chomsky and one of the members of the audience. (I am copying this from the Appendix in the Ludlow book (p. 187).)

***
Audience: ...what kind of empirical evidence would count in adjudicating between those.

NC: ... What is the empirical evidence that bears on whether anaphora is on one or the other side of the border of the language faculty? Well, part of the empirical evidence -- in my mind at least -- turns on whether in fact there's a single cycle derivational process that goes by, what I call phases, stepwise. That's an empirical question but all kinds of things bear on it coming from everywhere. And once that empirical question is sharpened, you can ask whether the global property of anaphora is inside or outside.
***

That's an empirical question. Perhaps it is. But how can we go about answering it on the basis of rigorous experiments? My book proposes what I consider to be the first step toward doing that.

References :
[44337] Hajime Hoji Apr/18/2014 (13:28)Anaphora, inside or outside the language faculty