The following examples are from Lasnik, Howard. 2001, "When Can You Save a Structure by Destroying It?" NELS 31: 301-320, and these appear to pose a problem for the proposal in Fukaya 2003. We will try to address the relevant issues under this posting.
(1) a. (= Lasnik 2001: (51)) Every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized some of hisi work, but I'm not sure how much of hisi work [every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized t] b. (= Lasnik 2001: (52)) Every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized some of hisi work. Tell me how much of hisi work [every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized t]
(2) a. (= Lasnik 2001: (53)) ??Every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized some of hisi work, but I'm not sure how much of hisi work the philosopher criticized t b. (= Lasnik 2001: (54)) ?*Every linguisti met a philosopher who criticized some of hisi work. Tell me how much of hisi work the philosopher criticized t.
(3) a. (= Lasnik 2001: (55)) Each of the linguists met a philosopher who criticized some of the other linguists, but I'm not sure how many of the other linguists b. (= Lasnik 2001: (56)) ?*How many of the other linguists did the philosopher criticize |